There’s a particular kind of optimism that seems to exist only in the grocery store.
You’re standing in the snack aisle, holding a package of something you absolutely love. Something you’ve purchased dozens of times. Something you know, from considerable personal experience, you struggle to eat in moderation.
And yet, you hear yourself making a familiar promise.
This time will be different.
This time you’ll only eat a serving. This time you’ll make the package last all week. This time you’ll demonstrate the kind of self-control you’ve apparently been developing since the last time you bought it.
Maybe it’s potato chips. Maybe it’s peanut butter. Maybe it’s ice cream. Or maybe it’s one of those keto-friendly treats that technically fits your macros but somehow disappears from your pantry at an alarming rate.
Whatever the food, you know the routine.
You buy it with the very best intentions.
And then, sometime between unloading the groceries and watching television that evening, those intentions quietly disappear.
The next thing you know, you’re staring at an empty package and wondering why you keep doing this to yourself.
But I’ve been thinking about something.
What if this behavior isn’t simply a failure of willpower? What if there are psychological reasons we keep repeating the same decisions, even when experience tells us how they’re likely to end?
As it turns out, researchers have been studying pieces of this puzzle for decades.
And understanding what they’ve discovered might change the way you shop.
Grocery Store You Has Never Met Nine-O’Clock-at-Night You
One of the most fascinating explanations comes from behavioral economist George Loewenstein, who studied something called the hot-cold empathy gap.
Essentially, human beings aren’t particularly good at predicting how they’ll behave when their emotional or physical state changes.
When we’re calm, comfortable, and satisfied, we tend to underestimate the influence that hunger, stress, exhaustion, and strong emotions will have on our future choices.
Think about that for a minute.
You’re standing in the grocery store at two o’clock in the afternoon. You’ve already eaten lunch. You’re feeling motivated. You’ve been doing great with keto.
Of course you believe you can eat two cookies and put the rest away.
Why wouldn’t you?
But at nine o’clock that night, you’ve had a long day. You’re exhausted. Maybe you’re frustrated about something. Maybe you’re bored. Maybe you finally have a few minutes to yourself and want something enjoyable.
Suddenly, those cookies in the pantry seem considerably more interesting.
The problem isn’t necessarily that you were lying to yourself in the grocery store.
You genuinely believed what you were saying.
You simply made a promise for a version of yourself whose circumstances you weren’t accurately anticipating.
And this is where I think we need to become a little more practical.
Maybe we should stop shopping exclusively for the person we hope we’ll be later and start considering the person experience has shown us we are when we’re tired, stressed, or hungry.
That’s not admitting defeat.
That’s learning from experience.
Sometimes We’re Not Buying the Food. We’re Buying the Fantasy.
Here’s something else I find interesting.
Why is it so important to us that we learn to moderate certain foods?
Why do we feel like we should be able to keep a package of cookies in the house for three weeks?
Why do we admire someone who can open a bag of chips, eat six, and put the bag away without giving it another thought?
I suspect that sometimes we aren’t even buying the food because we particularly want it.
We’re buying the fantasy of being the kind of person who can eat it without thinking about it.
We want to feel normal.
We want to feel disciplined.
We want to prove that we’ve finally conquered something that used to control us.
But who decided that being able to eat two cookies is the ultimate demonstration of a healthy relationship with food?
Nobody receives a trophy for keeping ice cream in the freezer.
There’s no moral superiority in being able to eat three potato chips instead of thirty.
And choosing not to buy something doesn’t mean you haven’t grown.
In fact, it might demonstrate exactly the opposite.
Maybe you’ve finally learned that you don’t need to keep testing yourself.
Food Isn’t Just Food in Our Society
There’s also a social side to this conversation that I think we overlook.
Food has become so intertwined with our celebrations, relationships, entertainment, and emotions that choosing not to eat something can almost feel like rejecting an experience.
We have birthday cake, holiday cookies, movie popcorn, vacation desserts, office donuts, and Friday-night pizza.
We celebrate with food.
We comfort ourselves with food.
We reward ourselves with food.
And sometimes we use food to show other people that we care about them.
Psychologist Suzanne Higgs reviewed research showing that social eating norms influence both what we eat and how much we consume.
In other words, our food decisions aren’t always as independent as we imagine.
We notice what other people eat. We absorb expectations about what is appropriate. We sometimes adjust our behavior because we want to fit in.
And when we’re following keto, those pressures can become particularly noticeable.
Suddenly, not eating the birthday cake requires an explanation.
Passing on dessert becomes a conversation.
And bringing your own food to a gathering can make you feel like the odd person out.
So perhaps part of our desire to learn moderation isn’t really about hunger at all.
Perhaps it’s about wanting to participate without feeling different.
But here’s something worth remembering.
You don’t have to eat like everyone else to enjoy being with everyone else.
And you certainly don’t have to prove you can keep every tempting food in your pantry to be a well-adjusted adult.
The Strange Way We Reward Ourselves for Doing Well
Have you ever noticed that success can sometimes become the very reason we abandon the habits that created it?
You’ve been consistent with keto for several weeks.
You’re feeling better.
Your clothes fit more comfortably.
Maybe the scale has even moved.
And suddenly you think, I’ve been doing so well. I deserve a treat.
It’s fascinating when you think about it.
We sometimes use our progress as permission to make a decision that moves us away from the very thing we’re celebrating.
Psychologists have studied a related phenomenon called self-licensing.
Research by Sosja Prinsen and colleagues found that when people were given a justification for indulgence, they were more likely to select or consume higher-calorie snacks in their experiments.
This doesn’t mean enjoying an occasional treat is inherently harmful.
But it does suggest that the stories we tell ourselves about why we deserve something can influence our choices.
And keto adds another interesting layer.
Sometimes we wouldn’t dream of purchasing an ordinary package of cookies.
But put the word KETO on the front, advertise two net carbs, and suddenly we’re much more comfortable putting it in the cart.
We focus on whether the food is technically compatible with our diet instead of asking whether it’s compatible with our actual behavior.
And those are two very different questions.
Because a food can fit your macros and still not fit your life.
A keto cookie might be perfectly enjoyable for one person and something another person consistently struggles to moderate.
Neither person’s experience determines the other’s.
The important thing is being honest about your own.
The Grocery Store Knows Exactly What It’s Doing
We also need to acknowledge that grocery stores aren’t designed simply to help us purchase what we need.
They’re designed to encourage us to buy.
Bright packaging. End-cap displays. Seasonal flavors. Limited-time promotions. Buy-one-get-one-free offers.
Even the size of a package can influence the decisions we make.
Research involving supermarket transactions has found substantial associations between promotions and increases in product sales.
Of course, that doesn’t mean every purchase is the result of clever marketing.
But it does mean we’re making decisions in an environment designed to capture our attention and encourage spending.
And how often have we purchased something simply because it was a good deal?
You weren’t planning to buy the ice cream.
But it’s buy one, get one free.
You weren’t looking for keto brownies.
But there’s a new flavor.
You didn’t need a giant bag of snacks.
But the family size costs less per ounce.
We convince ourselves we’re being smart consumers.
Yet sometimes we’re spending money on foods we weren’t planning to eat and may later regret purchasing.
Here’s a thought worth considering.
A sale isn’t saving you money if it convinces you to buy something you didn’t need in the first place.
Especially when the purchase also makes your health goals harder to manage.
Why Your Pantry Might Be Working Against You
One of the most practical lessons from behavioral science is that our environment matters.
Many of our habits become connected to particular situations.
Watching television might trigger the desire to snack.
Finishing dinner might make us want something sweet.
Walking into the kitchen after a stressful day might automatically lead us toward the pantry.
Over time, these behaviors can become so familiar that we barely notice the decision happening.
And when the food is readily available, following that familiar routine becomes incredibly convenient.
Think about the difference between resisting a package of cookies once at the grocery store and resisting that same package every evening after dinner.
One decision happens at the store.
The other might happen repeatedly throughout the week.
Sometimes we treat the second option as evidence of greater discipline.
But why?
Why do we believe we should constantly expose ourselves to something we find difficult simply to prove we can resist it?
We don’t have to make every healthy decision harder than necessary.
Sometimes the smartest choice isn’t developing superhuman willpower.
It’s creating an environment that requires less of it.
You don’t have to win a battle with your pantry every night if you stop bringing the battle home.
So How Do We Actually Break the Cycle?
I think the first step is to stop treating our past experiences as unfortunate accidents and start treating them as useful information.
Before purchasing a food you’ve struggled with repeatedly, ask yourself a very simple question.
What happened the last three times I brought this home?
Not what did I intend to do.
Not what did I promise myself.
What actually happened?
If you enjoyed a serving and moved on, wonderful.
But if you repeatedly ate more than you wanted, spent days thinking about the rest of the package, or found yourself feeling frustrated afterward, why wouldn’t you consider that information before buying it again?
Your past doesn’t determine your future.
But it can certainly help you make better predictions.
Another helpful strategy comes from research on something called implementation intentions.
That’s a complicated name for a very simple idea.
Instead of saying, “I’m going to make better choices,” you decide ahead of time what you’ll do in a particular situation.
For example:
If I see a new keto treat at the grocery store, I’ll take a picture of it and give myself a day to decide whether I really want it.
If I find myself wanting to buy a large package of something I’ve repeatedly overeaten, I’ll consider purchasing a smaller portion instead.
If I notice I’m buying food because I’ve had a stressful day, I’ll ask myself what I’m actually looking for before making the purchase.
Research has found that these specific if-then plans can help people translate healthy intentions into actual behavior, although the effects vary and aren’t a guarantee.
The important part is that you’re making a decision before you’re caught up in the moment.
And that can be incredibly valuable.
I also think we should reconsider what we’re trying to accomplish when we buy certain foods.
Are we buying them because we genuinely want to enjoy them?
Or are we buying them because we want to prove something?
Because those aren’t necessarily the same motivation.
There is nothing wrong with enjoying food.
And I don’t believe a healthy lifestyle should require us to live in fear of an occasional dessert.
But I also don’t believe we should feel obligated to continually purchase foods that make our lives more difficult simply to demonstrate that we have self-control.
Sometimes maturity is recognizing that you don’t need to prove anything.
Maybe Food Freedom Doesn’t Mean What We Think It Means
We talk a lot about food freedom.
And I think it’s an important conversation.
But I wonder whether we’ve sometimes confused freedom with access.
We assume that true food freedom means being able to keep anything in the pantry, eat anything whenever we want, and never experience temptation.
But what if freedom looks different?
What if freedom means walking through the grocery store without feeling compelled to buy every interesting product?
What if it means no longer thinking about the cookies sitting in the cabinet?
What if it means being able to enjoy a holiday without making food the center of every conversation?
What if it means understanding your own habits well enough to make decisions that support the life you want?
For some people, moderation works beautifully.
For others, certain foods may be easier to enjoy occasionally rather than keeping them constantly available.
And for someone who struggles with restrictive eating or episodes of losing control around food, increasingly rigid food rules may make things worse rather than better. Those patterns deserve support and compassion, not another reason to feel ashamed.
There isn’t one universal definition of a healthy relationship with food.
But I think it should include honesty, flexibility, and the ability to make choices without constantly attaching your worth to what you eat.
The Most Important Question to Ask Before You Buy It
The next time you’re standing in the grocery store holding that familiar package, I want you to consider asking yourself something different.
Instead of asking, Can I fit this into my macros?
Instead of asking, Do I deserve this?
Instead of asking, Shouldn’t I be able to eat this in moderation by now?
Ask yourself:
Will buying this make the life I’m trying to build easier or harder?
That’s it.
Not whether the food is good or bad.
Not whether you’re strong enough.
Not whether someone else can eat it without a second thought.
Just whether the purchase is likely to support the choices you genuinely want to make.
Maybe you’ll buy it.
Maybe you’ll choose something different.
Maybe you’ll put it back and realize you didn’t want it nearly as much as you thought.
Whatever you decide, the goal is to stop repeating the same automatic patterns and start making choices informed by your actual experience.
Because after years of working on our health, I think one of the most valuable lessons we can learn is that we don’t have to make everything a test of willpower.
We can make things easier for ourselves.
We can learn from what hasn’t worked.
We can recognize that the person we are today has more information than the person who made those decisions yesterday.
And we can stop confusing self-control with the willingness to make life unnecessarily difficult.
Maybe the next level of growth isn’t finally being able to eat just one cookie.
Maybe it’s realizing that you don’t need to keep buying the cookies to prove that you’ve changed.
Sometimes freedom isn’t having everything available to you. It’s knowing you have the power to choose what deserves a place in your life.
And that includes what’s in your grocery cart.


👍🏼