September has arrived.
You know what that means.
Apparently, EVERYTHING MUST NOW TASTE LIKE A PUMPKIN.
Coffee? Pumpkin.
Muffins? Pumpkin.
Cookies? Pumpkin.
Protein bars? Pumpkin.
Cereal? Pumpkin.
Creamer? Pumpkin.
Something that has absolutely no business being anywhere near a pumpkin? PUMPKIN.
Walk into a grocery store in September and you’d think America had just discovered pumpkins.
And if you’re keto, there’s an additional phenomenon that happens every fall.
We don’t just see the pumpkin spice stuff.
We immediately start trying to figure out: “HOW CAN I KETO-FY THAT?”
Friends, we’ve been doing keto long enough to know something: Give the keto community almond flour, cream cheese, a sugar substitute, and access to Pinterest, and we will find a way to recreate absolutely anything.
The question is no longer whether we can.
The question is whether some of this stuff is actually worth the trouble.
Let’s Get One Thing Straight: I Am NOT the Keto Fun Police
If you came here expecting me to tell you to eat ribeye, drink black coffee, and stare angrily at anyone holding a pumpkin muffin, you’re going to be disappointed.
I like fun food.
I like seasonal food.
And I definitely like finding ways to enjoy something without feeling like garbage afterward.
There are some things that are 100% worth keto-fying.
Pumpkin cheesecake? Absolutely.
Pumpkin pie at Thanksgiving? I’m listening.
Pumpkin spice coffee without dumping a day’s worth of sugar into your cup? Yes.
Keto Chow pumpkin ice cream in the CREAMi?You don’t have to ask me twice.
If it’s something you genuinely enjoy, it fits into your life, and having a keto version helps you stay consistent without feeling deprived, I think that’s fantastic.
That’s what keto alternatives are supposed to be.
Tools.
But somewhere along the way, we got really good at turning tools into hobbies.
And occasionally hobbies into full-time jobs.
Did You Even Like This Food Before Keto?
This is where things get funny.
Every September, some new pumpkin spice product shows up.
And suddenly we need a keto version.
But I have a question. Did you even eat that before keto?
Were you sitting around in 2015 saying: “Joe, fall just isn’t fall without pumpkin spice granola clusters”?
Probably not.
But now someone posts a keto version on Instagram and suddenly we’re ordering six ingredients from Amazon.
I’ve learned to ask myself: Do I actually want this—or did somebody just remind me that I’m supposed to want it?
Because those aren’t the same thing.
Food companies are very good at creating urgency around food.
LIMITED TIME!
SEASONAL!
ONLY AVAILABLE THIS FALL!
GET IT BEFORE IT’S GONE!
And our brains immediately hear: YOU ARE ABOUT TO MISS SOMETHING IMPORTANT.
Meanwhile, it’s a cookie.
Sometimes We Keto-Fy the Food but Not the Behavior
This is the part I think deserves more attention.
You can replace the sugar.
You can replace the flour.
You can replace the ingredients.
But sometimes we’re still practicing the exact same behavior.
Before keto: “I saw seasonal cookies at the store, so I bought them.”
After keto: “I saw seasonal cookies at the store, so I went home and spent three hours making a keto version.”
Technically, we changed the food.
But did we change our relationship with food?
That’s worth thinking about.
Because for me, one of the most valuable things about eating this way isn’t discovering that I can make a keto version of practically anything.
It’s discovering: I don’t need everything anymore.
I can see food without eating it.
I can smell something without buying it.
I can watch someone else enjoy something without needing my own version.
I can walk past a seasonal display and think: “That looks good.” And keep walking.
That might not make an impressive Instagram Reel.
But it’s incredibly useful.
Welcome to the $47 Keto Muffin
You know this recipe.
“Easy Keto Pumpkin Muffins!”
Easy?
Okay.
Let’s look at the ingredients.
Almond flour.
Coconut flour.
Powdered sweetener.
Granulated sweetener.
Pumpkin puree.
Pumpkin pie spice.
Cream cheese.
Heavy cream.
Sugar-free chocolate chips.
Xanthan gum.
And some mysterious ingredient available exclusively from a monastery in northern Sweden.
Now we’ve spent $47.
The kitchen looks like a crime scene.
We’ve used nine bowls.
And after 90 minutes of work…WE HAVE SIX MUFFINS.
And one of them somehow tastes like a kitchen sponge.
If baking is your hobby, HAVE FUN.
There is nothing wrong with that.
But if you’re tired, hungry, overwhelmed, and just trying to stay consistent with keto?
You know what’s easier than a pumpkin spice keto muffin? A cheeseburger.
Sometimes useful wins.
Ask What Job the Food Is Doing
This is the question I wish I had asked more often throughout my weight-loss journey. What job is this food doing?
Is it part of a family tradition?
Is it something I genuinely love?
Will making a keto version help me navigate Thanksgiving without feeling deprived?
Will my grandkids enjoy making it with me?
Does it make this lifestyle easier to maintain?
Great.
Keto-fy the heck out of it.
But what if the answer is: “Because it’s September.”
“Because everybody else is making it.”
“Because Costco put it on an endcap.”
“Because Instagram showed it to me 37 times.”
“Because I’m afraid I’m missing out.”
That’s different.
Maybe we don’t actually want the food.
Maybe we’re just responding to the cue.
And those are the moments where I think it’s worth stopping and asking: Is this useful—or is this just seasonal advertising?
Keto Doesn’t Have to Recreate the Standard American Diet
This may be an unpopular opinion.
I don’t think the ultimate goal of keto should be figuring out how to recreate every single food we used to eat.
Keto cereal.
Keto bread.
Keto cookies.
Keto brownies.
Keto chips.
Keto candy.
Keto donuts.
Keto cinnamon rolls.
Keto pumpkin spice whatever.
Again, none of these foods are automatically “bad.”
That’s not the point.
The point is: If we need keto versions of everything we used to eat in order to be happy, did we actually build a new lifestyle—or did we just remodel the old one?
That’s a question only you can answer.
And your answer might change over time.
Something that was incredibly useful during year one of keto might not be useful anymore.
That’s okay.
We’re allowed to grow.
There Is Always Another Food Holiday Coming
This is another thing nobody tells you.
September: pumpkin spice.
October: Halloween candy.
November: Thanksgiving.
December: Christmas cookies.
January: “I need to get back on track.”
February: Valentine’s candy.
March: Easter candy starts appearing approximately 11 minutes after Valentine’s Day.
Summer: ice cream, cookouts, vacations.
Then suddenly…PUMPKIN SPICE IS BACK.
There is no magical part of the calendar where society stops trying to feed us.
If your strategy requires the world to stop offering tempting food, you’re going to be waiting a very long time.
Eventually we have to develop another skill: Being around food without needing to participate in all of it.
That’s freedom.
You Can Celebrate Fall Without Eating Fall
This sounds ridiculously obvious when you say it out loud.
But sometimes we need the reminder.
Fall is not a flavor.
You can enjoy football without eating for the entire game.
You can go to a pumpkin patch without consuming a pumpkin.
You can light the pumpkin spice candle.
You can decorate the porch.
You can watch the leaves change.
Or, if you’re in Florida like us, you can watch the palm trees remain exactly the same while sweating through your fall outfit.
You can enjoy September without turning every meal into a seasonal event.
And yes…You can also make pumpkin cheesecake.
Because this isn’t about restriction.
It’s about intention.
So What IS Worth Keto-Fying?
My rule has become pretty simple.
Keto-fy the foods that make your keto life easier, happier, or more sustainable.
Keep the traditions that matter.
Make the dessert you truly love.
Find an alternative that helps you navigate a difficult situation.
Enjoy seasonal flavors because you genuinely enjoy them.
But don’t feel obligated to recreate every food the internet tells you you’re missing.
You aren’t missing anything.
And you definitely don’t need a 14-ingredient muffin just because the calendar says September.
Maybe This Is What Food Freedom Looks Like
When we first start keto, freedom can feel like discovering substitutes.
“Wait! I can still have pizza?”
“I can make ice cream?”
“There’s keto bread?”
That’s exciting.
And sometimes those alternatives are exactly what we need.
But I think there’s another kind of freedom that can come later.
It’s being able to say: “I could make a keto version…but I don’t really care.”
That’s huge.
Not because you’ve become more disciplined.
Not because you’re doing “better keto.”
But because food doesn’t have quite as much power over your attention anymore.
So this pumpkin spice season, enjoy the things you actually enjoy.
Make the pumpkin cheesecake.
Put cinnamon in your coffee.
Make the pumpkin ice cream.
And if someone announces they’ve created a keto pumpkin spice maple pecan caramel cinnamon-roll breakfast cookie…
You are allowed to say: “That sounds delicious.”And then go fry some bacon.
Because the goal isn’t to become better at keto-fying everything.
The goal is to build a life where we don’t feel like we need everything in the first place.
And sometimes the most freeing keto recipe…is the one you don’t bother making.


I enjoy looking at recipes that as you say ketofy something that looks delicious. But again I enjoy looking at the recipes seeing someone else make it and then they give their opinion whether it’s worth the trouble or not I enjoy watching those. However, you’re right if it requires 18 ingredients and $47 to make that recipe thank you, but I’ll pass again. We can look at all sorts of things, but we don’t need to feel the urge to participate in those things. Thanks for the reminder.
I do enjoy a good pumpkin ice coffee ☕